Auto Lock vs. Screwgate Carabiners – Which Is Stronger?

There’s been a lot of debate lately about which type of carabiner is stronger – auto lock or screwgate? Some say that auto lock carabiners are stronger because they have a locking mechanism that prevents the gate from opening accidentally. Others say that screwgate carabiners are stronger because they can be tightened down more securely. So, which is the true winner? Let’s find out!

How do auto lock and screwgate carabiners work?

There are two main types of carabiners: auto lock and screwgate. And they work in different ways:

  • Auto lock carabiners have a mechanism that automatically locks the gate closed when it is released. This provides a high degree of security but can be tricky to open if you’re not familiar with the mechanism.
  • Screwgate carabiners have a gate that must be screwed shut in order to secure it. This can be done by hand or with a tool, making it more secure than an auto-lock carabiner. However, it is also more time-consuming to close and open. Screwgate carabiners are more secure because it is more difficult for the gate to open accidentally. However, they can be more difficult to open when you need to use them.

Both types of carabiners are strong, but screwgate carabiners are typically stronger because of their design.

What are the benefits of using auto lock or screwgate carabiners?

There are a few different types of locking carabiners on the market, but the two most popular are auto lock and screwgate carabiners. Both have their own benefits and drawbacks, so it’s important to choose the right one for your needs.

  • Auto lock carabiners are great for ease of use. Simply clip them onto your gear and they will automatically lock into place. This means you don’t have to worry about fumbling with a locking mechanism in the middle of an activity. However, auto lock carabiners are not as strong as screwgate carabiners and can be more prone to failure.
  • Screwgate carabiners are much stronger than auto lock carabiners and are less likely to fail. However, they require you to manually screw the locking mechanism into place, which can be difficult to do in the middle of an activity.

How strong are auto lock and screwgate carabiners?

The strength of a carabiner is important to consider when purchasing one because it will dictate how safe the carabiner is to use. There are two main types of carabiners – auto lock and screwgate – and both have different strength ratings.

  • Auto lock carabiners are typically stronger than screwgate carabiners because they have a locking mechanism that prevents the gate from opening unless it is released.
  • Screwgate carabiners do not have this locking mechanism, which means that they are not as strong as auto-lock carabiners.

What are the drawbacks of using auto lock or screwgate carabiners?

There are a few potential drawbacks to using auto lock or screwgate carabiners:

  • First, if you’re not familiar with how to use them, they can be tricky to open and close. Make sure you read the instructions before using one of these types of carabiners.
  • Another potential drawback is that, because they’re so easy to open and close, it’s possible to accidentally leave one open. This could create a dangerous situation if you’re climbing or hiking and need to rely on your carabiner to be secure.
  • Finally, both auto lock and screwgate carabiners are more expensive than traditional models. However, many people feel that the extra cost is worth it for the added safety and security they provide.

Which type of carabiner is best for different situations?

Auto lock and screwgate carabiners each have their own advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to choose the right one for the job.

  • Auto lock carabiners are quick and easy to use, making them great for general climbing and belaying. However, they can be difficult to open with one hand, so they’re not ideal for emergency situations.
  • Screwgate carabiners are more secure than auto lock carabiners, making them ideal for use in rappelling or other situations where there is a risk of the carabiner coming undone. However, they take longer to open and close, so they’re not as convenient for everyday use.

How to choose the right auto lock or screwgate carabiner?

When it comes to choosing the right auto lock or screwgate carabiner for your application, first consider the weight, dimensions, gate type, and materials of the carabiner. Then decide on the opening size, and determines how close the two arms of the carabiner need to be in order for it to function properly. For instance, To be used in life support/safety systems, a minimum breaking strength (MBS) for carabiners of 20 kN (4,496 lbf) is required for all major axis points and 11 kN (2,498 lbf) for all minor axis points.

How to use auto lock and screwgate carabiners safely?

Both auto lock and screwgate carabiners are designed for strength and safety, but there are some important differences to keep in mind when choosing which type to use.

  • Auto lock carabiners have a spring-loaded mechanism that keeps the gate closed and locked until it is released by depressing a button or lever. This can be handy if you need to attach or release the carabiner quickly, but it also means that there is a potential for the gate to open unintentionally if the button or lever is accidentally depressed.
  • Screwgate carabiners have a screw-type mechanism that needs to be manually opened and closed. This prevents accidental opening but can be slower to operate. When choosing a carabiner, consider the type of activity you will be using it for and whether the quick operation or extra security is more important. Both types of carabiners are safe and effective when used properly.

In Closing

Both auto-lock and screwgate carabiners are strong and effective at keeping a person safe when working or playing at heights. However, each has its limits and drawbacks so make sure to only use the right one for the activity you will be doing.

NEXT UP: Carabiner vs. Shackle vs. Quick Link – Pros & Cons

Did you find this useful? If yes please share!
Jack Harrison
About Jack Harrison

JT Harrison is an expert Survival Instructor, focused on wilderness and urban survival techniques. He focuses on survival, prepping, food, water, shelter and other essential steps individuals and families can take to live for long periods outdoors, or in crisis situations. JT has been trekking and climbing for 20+ years in some of the harshest environments in the world. Learn more about JT here or connect with him on Twitter

× How can we help you?