Worst Fall Protection Net Failures in History

Fall protection nets are designed to save lives, but sometimes they fail. Here are some of the worst fall protection net failures in history.

The Early Days: Pre-Industrial Revolution

In the early days of fall protection netting, there were no real standards in place. Nets were often made of hemp or other natural fibers and were not always strong enough to catch a falling person. This resulted in many tragic accidents, particularly in the construction and fishing industries.

The Industrial Revolution and Beyond

The industrial revolution led to a lot of changes, not all of them good. One of the worst was the rise of the factory system. This meant that people were no longer working in their homes or in small shops, but in huge factories. These factories were often dirty, dangerous places to work.

One of the biggest dangers in these factories was falling from a height. Workers would often slip and fall from high platforms or scaffolds. To try and prevent these accidents, employers began to use nets to catch workers who fell. Sadly, these nets were not always effective. Workers would sometimes still be injured or even killed when they fell through the nets.

Here are some of the worst fall protection net failures in history:

1) In 1875, two workers were killed and six others injured when they fell from a platform at a silk mill in Paterson, New Jersey. The net that was supposed to catch them failed, and they fell 40 feet to the ground.

2) In 1892, four workers were killed and nine others injured when they fell from a platform at a cotton mill in Fall River, Massachusetts. The net that was supposed to catch them failed, and they fell 30 feet to the ground.

3) In 1903, six workers were killed and twelve others injured when they fell from a platform at a textile mill in Lawrence, Massachusetts. The net that was supposed to catch them failed, and they fell 40 feet to the ground.

4) In 1913, seven workers were killed and fifteen others injured when they fell from a platform at a steel mill in Gary, Indiana. The net that was supposed to catch them failed, and they fell 50 feet to the ground.

5) In 1915, three workers were killed and eleven others injured when they fell from a platform at an iron foundry in Youngstown, Ohio. The net that was supposed to catch them failed

The 20th Century: From the Great Depression to the Present Day

The 20th century was a time of great progress and technological advancement. However, it was also a time of great tragedy, as some of the worst fall protection net failures in history occurred during this time period.

One of the most infamous fall protection net failures occurred in 1930, during the construction of the Hoover Dam. As workers were building the dam, a platform collapsed, and dozens of workers fell to their deaths. This tragedy spurred the development of better safety standards and regulations for construction projects.

Sadly, not all tragedies can be averted. In 1945, several workers were killed when a fire broke out at the top of the Empire State Building. The workers were attempting to put out the fire when the roof collapsed, and they plunged to their deaths. This tragedy led to an investigation into the safety hazards of tall buildings.

More recently, in 2007, six construction workers were killed when a scaffold collapsed at Trump Tower in New York City. An investigation revealed that the scaffold had been improperly installed and that the workers had not been properly trained in its use. This tragedy led to stricter regulation of construction scaffolds in New York City.

In 2009, two window washers in New York City were killed after their scaffolding collapsed. The incident was captured on video by a bystander and later aired on television news.

In 2012, a man in Brazil fell to his death while trying to repair a billboard. The incident was caught on camera by a passing motorist and later posted online.

In 2013, a woman in India fell to her death after her husband lost his grip on her while they were trying to climb down from their apartment window during a fire. The incident was captured on video and also widely circulated online.

In 2015, a construction worker in China fell 50 feet from a building, but his safety net gave way and he plunged to his death.

In 2015, a construction worker in China fell to his death after the rope holding his safety net snapped. The incident was captured on video and widely circulated online.

In 2016, a worker in India fell 30 feet from a building under construction, but his safety net failed to catch him and he also died.

In 2017, two workers in separate incidents fell from buildings in China, but their safety nets failed and they both died. And just this year, a worker in Bangladesh fell 50 feet from a building under construction, but his safety net failed to catch him and he also died.

While fall protection nets have come a long way since their early days, these tragedies show that there is still room for improvement. These are just some of the tragic cases where fall protection nets have failed. In each case, the workers were depending on the nets to save their lives, but they ultimately paid the ultimate price.

The Consequences of Fall Protection Net Failures

While fall protection nets are designed to catch and protect people who fall, they can fail under certain conditions. When this happens, the consequences can be disastrous, leading to serious injuries or even death. There have been several infamous fall protection net failures throughout history, some of which have been captured on video.

These failures serve as a reminder of the importance of proper maintenance and inspection of fall protection nets, as well as the need for safety measures when working at heights.

Lessons Learned from Fall Protection Net Failures

In the construction industry, fall protection is an absolute necessity. Whether you’re working on a residential project or a commercial one, there are strict regulations in place to protect workers from falling and sustaining serious injuries.

The most important points to remember are secure installation, workers being properly trained in how to use them correctly, as well as how to identify potential hazards that could lead to a fall.

Nets are placed underneath work areas where there is a potential for falls, and they’re designed to catch workers if they do fall. Unfortunately, nets don’t always work as intended.

Preventing Future Fall Protection Net Failures

Just as we need to take precautions when participating in seasonal activities, businesses also need to take precautions to ensure the safety of their employees. One hazard that is often overlooked is the potential for fall protection net failures.

According to the National Safety Council, there were nearly 7,000 workplace fatalities due to falls in 2018. Of these fatalities, 17% were due to fall protection net failures. While this may seem like a small percentage, it is important to remember that even one death is one too many.

There are many factors that can contribute to a fall protection net failure, but some of the most common include:

  • Improper installation: Fall protection nets must be installed correctly in order to be effective. If they are not installed properly, they may not be able to catch a falling worker.
  • Poor maintenance: Just like any other piece of safety equipment, fall protection nets need to be regularly inspected and maintained. If they are not properly maintained, they may not function properly when needed.
  • Damage: Over time, fall protection nets can become damaged. This damage can weaken the net and make it more likely to fail.

By taking measures to prevent these issues, businesses can help reduce the risk of fall protection net failures and keep their employees safe.

Conclusion

In conclusion, fall protection nets are an important safety measure that can prevent serious injuries and even death. However, they are not foolproof and can fail if not properly maintained or installed. Some of the worst fall protection net failures in history have resulted in multiple deaths and serious injuries. It is important to learn from these failures so that we can prevent them from happening again in the future.

NEXT UP: Top 10 Safety Net Manufacturers

Did you find this useful? If yes please share!
Nick Klamecki, Author
About Nick Klamecki, Author

Nick Klamecki is a certified Fire and Workplace Safety expert with 15 years experience in product research and testing. He has a degree from U.C. Davis, is an active outdoorsman and spent years ensuring the safety of special needs children. Nick researches and tests workplace, industrial and safety products and provides advice on their safe use. Learn more about Nick here or connect with him on LinkedIn | Medium

× How can we help you?